JD Vance Starts New Racist Lie to Attack Immigrant Children
JD Vance just put a target on the back of every brown child in Michigan.
For all his talk of being a family man, JD Vance went out of his way Tuesday to put a target on the backs of children during a speech in Detroit, Michigan. But they’re the children of immigrants, so why would he care?
Vance was speaking about undocumented immigrants when he turned his attention specifically to school-age children.
“The other thing that is crazy about the border, is that in the state of Michigan—I didn’t know this statistic until today—there are 85,000 students in Michigan public schools who are the children of illegal aliens,” Vance claimed.
“Eighty-five thousand. Now think about that. Think about what it does to a poor school teacher, who’s just trying to get by with what they have, just trying to educate their kids, and then you drop in a few dozen kids into that school, many of whom don’t even speak English,” Vance said. “Do you think that’s good for the education of American citizens? No, it’s not.”
Here, Vance seems to have widened his net beyond targeting undocumented immigrant children, a plainly heinous rhetorical step in itself, to children who may very well be U.S. citizens by nature of being born here. It’s also worth noting that Vance has a penchant to falsely describe immigrants with protected legal status as “illegal,” so it’s unclear whom exactly he would include in this statistic.
While it’s also unclear where Vance got “85,000” children from, the number does appear on the Higher Education Immigration Portal, which states that there are 85,000 second-generation immigrant students attending higher education institutions in Michigan.
If this is in fact the number Vance is using, it’s worth noting that it has absolutely no relationship with U.S. public schools, school-aged children, or even undocumented immigrants. “Second-generation immigrants” refers to people born in the U.S. While Vance’s claim was specifically about the parents, there is no data that supports the claim that all of these students’ parents are undocumented.
In that same vein, it’s likely that these second-generation students would not struggle with English language proficiency. Way to go, Vance! That’s 0 for 4!
But let’s for a moment imagine that the number Vance gave was somehow correct. Even then, his alleged grievances start to fall apart.
In 2022, 1,433,914 students were enrolled in Michigan public schools, according to the National Center for Education Statistics. That means that Vance is claiming that roughly five percent of all students in the state are such a gross drain on resources that it has somehow diminished the quality of education for the other 95 percent. Perhaps Vance is right to be concerned about the waning quality of American education.
Vance’s blatant scapegoating makes no sense because it is not built on real concerns about the quality of education, or the “poor” teachers who might struggle to meet the needs of the classroom because of a lack of education funding. Rather, his claim is built on making racist distinctions between who “deserves” to have access to education and who should be kicked out as a cheap shot for votes in a battleground state.
“Look, I think we’re a great country, we can be compassionate, and we ought to be compassionate, but our compassion has to start with our fellow citizens, the people that deserve to be in the United States to begin with,” Vance said.
The Ohio senator touted Donald Trump’s plan for the largest mass deportations in the history of the United States as “the best way to be compassionate.”
Vance has previously invoked compassion as a quasi-religious justification for the blatantly bigoted immigration policies. Neither of Vance’s rhetorical lines are particularly new for the Trump campaign, which has repeatedly stressed the strain influxes of immigration can have on schools. But this goes to show how the Republican ticket has normalized rhetoric that targets the most vulnerable in our society.
Last month, Trump made a similar comment about non-English speaking students in schools in Charleroi, Pennsylvania, which was promptly debunked by the Charleroi school district superintendent. In fact, reimbursement from the Department of Education had actually increased as student enrollment increased—the very same Department of Education Trump hopes to dismantle.
Vance’s reckless targeting of school-age children and teenagers also happens to be in a state with the largest populations of Palestinian and Lebanese immigrants. Michigan has the second largest population of Arab immigrants in the U.S., and the highest with the highest percentage population in the country, according to the Arab American Institute.
This story has been updated.